|Anonymous | Login | Signup for a new account||2014-03-08 03:12 UTC|
|Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Roadmap|
|View Issue Details|
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0000669||OpenFOAM||[All Projects] Bug||public||2012-10-26 16:05||2012-10-29 12:37|
|Target Version||Fixed in Version|
|Summary||0000669: Wrong calculation of calculating Cp in addition operator in hConstThermo|
|Description||It seems to me that operator+ in hConstThermo calculates the Cp in a wrong way (and this applies also to Hf and to other arithmetical operators).|
Consider the following code:
int main(int argc, char *argv)
typedef constTransport<specieThermo<hConstThermo<perfectGas> > > ThermoType;
Info << "W= " << t1.W() << " " << t2.W() << " " << (t1+t2).W() << endl;
Info << "Cp= " << t1.cp(1) << " " << t2.cp(1) << " " << (t1+t2).cp(1) << endl;
Run it on the following thermo.dict file:
The program will output
W= 1 0.5 0.75
Cp= 1 1 1.125
However, the I expect the following output:
W= 1 0.5 0.75
Cp= 1 1 1
Indeed, here two species are defined having different molar masses (1 and 0.5 kg/kmol) and different heat capacitance per kg (1 and 2), but note that they have the same heat capacitance per mole --- 1 J/(kmol K).
The program reads both specie data, adds them, and outputs the resulting heat capacitance. As expected, cp() for both species separately is 1 (cp() returns J/(kmol K)). The heat capacitance per kilomole of mixture of these two species should therefore be 1 too, independently of the mixture composition, therefore the program should output 1, not 1.125.
As I understand it, the problems comes from the hConstThermo addition operator that calculates the thermal capacity by the following code (hConstThermoI.H, lines 209-210):
This would be correct if hConstThermo::Cp_ was the thermal capacity per mole (J/(kmol K) or J/(mol K)). However, Cp_ is the thermal capacity per kg (J/(kg K)) --- see, for example, hConstThermo::cp(), which returns J/(kmol K) and is implemented as Cp_*this->W().
So, the correct code should be something like
The same applies to Hf calculations and to other arithmetical operators in hConstThermo (operator-, operator+=, operator -=).
Note also that a similar code exists in janafThermo:
However, here highCpCpeffs_ are per mole, not per kg (and janafThermo::cp() does not refer to W() ), so this equation is a correct one.
|Tags||No tags attached.|
Thanks for the detailed bug-report.
On further consideration we have concluded that it would be better to convert the Cp_ and Hf_ to mole-based on input and back again on output in the same manner as in hPolynomialThermo which is more consistent and also resolves the issue you reported.
Resolved by commit 74eb38ab125c177165c9704f405bcbfe12cf26c8
|2012-10-26 16:05||pkalinin||New Issue|
|2012-10-29 12:37||henry||Note Added: 0001757|
|2012-10-29 12:37||henry||Status||new => resolved|
|2012-10-29 12:37||henry||Resolution||open => fixed|
|2012-10-29 12:37||henry||Assigned To||=> henry|